Westport Mortgage Dispute Turns on the Difference Between Current and Reinstated
A $39,861.97 mortgage statement appeared to tell a Westport borrower what he needed to pay to bring his loan current. But the loan had already been accelerated, and the amount required to reinstate it was higher. The Connecticut Appellate Court has now ruled that the statement did not reinstate the loan when the borrower sent the listed amount.
The distinction matters in mortgage servicing: an amount described as sufficient to bring an account current may not satisfy the separate conditions for reinstating a loan after acceleration. Here, the court’s decision turned on the loan documents, conversations between the borrower and Fay Servicing, and the timing of the payment.
A Westport loan in foreclosure
The dispute involves a $975,000 loan issued in 2005 by Washington Mutual Bank, secured by a property in Westport, Connecticut. The borrower signed the promissory note, while his wife mortgaged the property as security. The loan later passed from Washington Mutual to JPMorgan Chase, then through several trust assignments. U.S. Bank Trust, National Association, as owner trustee for VRMTG Asset Trust, ultimately held the loan. Fay Servicing managed it.
The borrowers fell behind, and the last installment Fay accepted came around October 2018. In January 2019, the servicer sent default notices stating that $15,556.60 was needed to cure the default by March 21. The notices warned that missing the deadline could lead to acceleration, making the full balance due. The borrowers did not meet the deadline, and the loan was accelerated.
That status shaped what came next. On April 29, 2019, the borrower called Fay to ask about the delinquency and reinstatement. A representative said the loan was in active foreclosure, a payment plan was unavailable, and reinstatement would require the past-due amount plus foreclosure fees and costs. She offered to request a formal reinstatement quote.
One statement, two different payment figures
Fay’s regular monthly statement, received on May 11, listed $39,861.97 as the past-due amount. In bold, it instructed the borrower: “You must pay this amount to bring your loan current.” A delinquency notice on the same statement identified $39,861.97 as the amount needed to cure the delinquency. The document also directed him to call for the amount necessary to reinstate the loan.
That wording left two figures in play. The statement showed the amount associated with bringing the account current, while Fay said reinstatement after acceleration required additional foreclosure expenses. The distinction was addressed directly in a second call on May 30. The borrower asked if he could use the statement to pay the arrears. The representative said it was a standard billing statement that did not include foreclosure fees and costs, and told him, “It’s not going to be that amount.”
Fay dated a reinstatement letter June 3, quoting $41,149.40 and setting a June 14 deadline. The company also called on June 6 and left a voicemail. The borrower said he did not receive the letter. He mailed a cashier’s check for $39,861.97 on June 7. Fay received it June 12 and returned it as insufficient to reinstate the loan.
Why the appeals court reversed
The borrowers challenged the foreclosure in Superior Court. In August 2024, the trial court found that the May statement amounted to an offer to bring the loan current, that the borrower’s payment supplied consideration for an agreement, and that the loan had been reinstated. The judge acknowledged that Fay had told the borrower the statement figure was not the reinstatement amount, while describing the distinction as confusing to consumers and even some lawyers.
A later ruling, issued in February 2025, ordered the borrowers to pay U.S. Bank $355,913.20 to bring the loan current and credited them $47,920.95 in attorney’s fees. The Connecticut Appellate Court reversed the earlier findings in a unanimous decision written by Judge Seeley.
The court found no evidence that both sides had agreed to reinstate the loan for $39,861.97. The borrower had been told in the April and May calls that the monthly statement did not state the reinstatement figure. The court concluded that, given those conversations and the agreed facts, a reasonable borrower would not have understood that paying the statement amount would reinstate an accelerated loan.
The claimed agreement also lacked consideration, the court said. The borrower’s promise to pay sums already owed under the note and mortgage could not serve as the basis for a new contract. The mortgage terms provided another reason: section 19 required payment of all sums due as if acceleration had not occurred, correction of other defaults, and payment of enforcement expenses, including attorney’s fees and property inspection costs.
Timing provided an additional obstacle. Even if the statement could be read as an offer, it listed June 1, 2019, as the payment due date. The borrower did not mail his check until June 7. The court rejected his argument that a later late-fee date extended the deadline, citing its ruling and the precedent in Sunset Mortgage v. Agolio: a grace period before a late fee applies does not change the payment’s due date.
Foreclosure returns to the trial court
The appellate panel agreed that U.S. Bank had established the basic grounds for foreclosure: it held the note and mortgage, the borrower had defaulted, and the required conditions had been met. It did not direct the trial court to enter a foreclosure judgment immediately. In Connecticut, foreclosure is an equitable proceeding, so the trial court retains discretion over the form and terms of any judgment.
The case returns to the trial court to determine the amount of the debt and whether, and on what terms, foreclosure should proceed. The appellate decision settles the reinstatement question, while leaving those remaining issues open.
For mortgage servicing and property professionals, the ruling draws a clear line between a routine statement balance and a reinstatement quote after acceleration. The language “bring your loan current” did not override the loan’s reinstatement terms or the servicer’s direct explanations. The case also shows how easily those figures can be confused when they appear in the same account process. The next step in the Westport dispute is a trial court determination of the debt and foreclosure judgment.