Condos, Co-ops and Leaseholds: What Apartment Buyers Face by Market

| 5 min read
Apartment complex with a pool

Most apartment buyers aren't buying an apartment in the traditional sense. The unit they're after is almost always a condo, a co-op, or in a few markets, a leasehold. Each one carries a different ownership structure, and that structure shapes what you pay, what you control, and how easy the place is to finance.

Before you tour a single unit in Boston or a condo in Portland, it helps to know which of these you're actually looking at.

What you can actually buy

The short answer: you can't buy a typical rental apartment. The apartment-style units people purchase fall into three groups. Condos are the most common. Co-ops are less frequent, and leaseholds are rare enough that many buyers never encounter one.

Leaseholds exist mainly in Hawaii, Florida, and New York. Under a leasehold, you own the right to occupy a unit for a fixed term rather than owning it outright. That distinction matters a great deal when you're comparing long-term costs.

Condos: individual ownership, shared obligations

A condo gives you title to a single unit inside a multi-unit building. You're responsible for the inside of your unit, and you share ownership of the common elements with everyone else in the building.

The recurring cost that catches first-time buyers off guard is the homeowners association fee. HOA dues pay for shared upkeep: roofs, landscaping, and amenities like pools and gyms. Because those dues depend entirely on what a building maintains, two condos priced the same can carry monthly costs that differ by hundreds of dollars.

Debbie Drummond of The Las Vegas Luxury Home Pro sees the tradeoff clearly. Traditional condo communities tend to have moderate dues. High-rise buildings often charge more because they offer services like doormen, valet parking, and front-desk staff. Drummond also points out that lenders count the HOA fee as part of your monthly housing expense, so a steep fee can shrink the mortgage you qualify for. If that fee pushes a high-rise purchase out of reach, renting may be the more sensible route.

Co-ops: shares instead of deeds

A co-op works differently. You don't buy real property. You buy shares in a nonprofit corporation that owns the building, and those shares give you the right to live in a specific unit.

Co-op owners carry the same kind of shared financial obligations as condo owners. Monthly charges cover building maintenance and upkeep, along with improvements to common areas. The difference is that the corporation's board typically has a say over who can buy in, which makes the approval process a real part of the transaction.

Leaseholds: time-limited ownership

A leasehold is closer to a long-term lease than to a traditional sale. Terms can run anywhere from 40 to 120 years. When the lease expires, the freeholder, usually the landlord, takes back ownership. Throughout the term, you hold the right to live in the unit, but you don't own the land under the building.

Leaseholders often pay ground rent on top of their other housing costs. Because the clock is always running, the remaining years on a lease affect resale value and financing in ways that a freehold never would.

There's an upside. Leaseholders often have more freedom to renovate than renters do. Rather than requesting permission for every change, you may be able to make improvements, depending on what your lease allows.

Your local market decides which option you'll see

Availability depends heavily on where you're shopping. Andrew Finney of King Realty Group in Las Vegas, NV reports that condos make up nearly all the apartment sales there, while co-ops and leaseholds are scarce.

That shifts the questions a Las Vegas buyer should ask. Finney says the HOA becomes the center of the deal. Buyers need to know what the monthly dues cover, how well the reserve fund is funded, and whether a special assessment is on the horizon. Financing is the other pressure point. Some condo projects aren't approved for FHA or VA loans, and some don't meet conventional lender guidelines, which narrows your options before you've even picked a unit. Finney's advice is to get pre-approved early so you know your borrowing limit before you start looking.

His broader point is worth keeping in mind. If you expect to stay put for several years, buying can beat renting. But compare the full monthly cost of ownership, including dues and insurance, against rent side by side before you commit.

What to weigh before you buy

Whether buying beats renting depends on your life more than on the building. Are you living alone or with roommates? How long will you stay? Do you expect to move for work within five years? There's no universal answer, but a few questions cut through the noise.

  • How much cash do you need? Condo and co-op buyers often put down anywhere from 3% to 20% of the purchase price. Closing costs come on top of that, and so do the ongoing expenses of ground rent or a mortgage, plus property taxes. An affordability calculator can help you work out a realistic number before you start shopping.
  • What's your timeline? Buying tends to pay off when you stay long enough to absorb the transaction costs. If you might need to sell quickly, the calculus changes, and a building's resale liquidity matters more.
  • What do the finances say? Your budget and timeline should come first, but the building's books deserve just as much attention.

Read the building's books before the unit

In a condo or co-op, you're sharing the cost of the whole structure, so the association's health matters as much as the kitchen you're admiring. Nick Booth of Nick Booth Real Estate in Salt Lake City, UT says many buyers underestimate that. He recommends requesting the HOA's reserve study and budget, a document most buyers never ask for. A thin reserve fund combined with spending that outpaces income is usually what produces the special assessments that surprise owners later.

Booth's test is simple: if you plan to stay at least five years and your total monthly cost lands close to what you'd pay in rent, buying tends to make sense. Once you've found a unit you like, a condo inspection will show you the unit's actual condition before you commit.

The bottom line on buying an apartment

Buying an apartment carries real advantages and real tradeoffs, and the right answer depends on how you live and how long you plan to stay. In Boston, Portland, or Las Vegas, the building's finances and the local lending rules will shape your options as much as the unit itself. If you're unsure, a mortgage lender or a local real estate agent can walk you through the numbers for your specific situation.

Frequently asked questions

1. What's the difference between an apartment and a condo?

An apartment is usually a rental unit in a building owned by a single landlord or company. A condo is a unit you own individually, along with a share of the building's common areas, and an HOA typically manages those shared spaces.

2. Can you get a mortgage for a condo or co-op?

Often, yes, but requirements vary by loan type and by building. Some condo projects aren't approved for FHA or VA loans, so ask a lender about the specific building early in your search.

3. What do HOA fees cover?

HOA fees generally pay for shared spaces and amenities, such as roofs, landscaping, and recreational facilities. What's included differs from building to building, so ask for a breakdown of the monthly dues.

4. What is a special assessment?

A special assessment is an additional charge an HOA can levy on owners, often to cover a major repair or a shortfall in reserves. Reviewing the reserve study and budget before you buy helps you gauge that risk.

5. Is buying an apartment cheaper than renting?

It depends on the building, the local market, and how long you plan to stay. Add up mortgage payments, HOA dues, insurance, and property taxes, then compare that total with the rent you'd pay. Redfin's rent vs. buy calculator can help structure that comparison.

Source: Emily Pascale · www.redfin.com