Multifamily Distress Creates Buying Opportunity as U.S. Apartment Supply Slows
Apartment fundamentals and apartment owners’ finances are moving in opposite directions. Renters absorbed more units than developers delivered in the second quarter, while delinquency among apartment loans packaged into commercial mortgage-backed securities rose to 7.69% in July. For Ivan Barratt, founder and CEO of Carmel, Indiana-based BAM Capital, that gap points to a rare buying window.

“This period is ‘the best buying opportunity I’ve seen’ in 16 years,” Barratt says. His view rests on a distinction that can get lost in rising delinquency figures: distress among owners doesn’t necessarily mean the apartments themselves are weak.
Demand is meeting a shrinking construction pipeline
CBRE reported that renters absorbed 167,500 apartments in the second quarter, more than twice the 77,700 units delivered. National vacancy fell to 4.3%, below its long-run average. At the same time, Trepp put the share of delinquent apartment loans in commercial mortgage-backed securities at 7.69% in July, more than a percentage point above the level two years earlier.
New supply is easing after the wave that weighed on rents in 2024 and 2025. Annual deliveries were about 340,000 units, down from nearly 590,000 at the late-2024 peak, according to RealPage. Completions fell below the decade average for the first time in three years, and construction starts are at their lowest since 2011.
That pullback reflects the economics of building. At current costs and financing rates, many proposed developments don’t pencil until rents rise. Existing properties could benefit as fewer competing units reach the market, particularly in submarkets where new construction has stalled.
Demand, meanwhile, has shifted toward renting. CBRE estimates that buying a home costs 105% more per month than renting one. With half of outstanding mortgages carrying rates below 4%, many current owners have little reason to sell, while prospective buyers face a much higher monthly payment. Barratt sees household formation continuing to support rentals, even as national rent growth remains around 1% year over year.
Loan maturities are adding pressure to owners
The financial strain traces back in part to deals made in 2021 and 2022. Many properties changed hands with floating-rate bridge loans, based on financing costs near 4% and expectations of 6% annual rent growth. Those assumptions have become harder to sustain as loans mature and refinancing requires more equity.
Roughly 13% of multifamily loans are due this year, the Mortgage Bankers Association estimates. Owners unable to refinance without a substantial cash injection are appearing in delinquency, receivership and foreclosure proceedings. Barratt says some sponsors who were active bidders in 2021 are now defaulting on loan pools worth hundreds of millions of dollars and surrendering thousands of units.
That pressure can produce discounts even where the buildings remain sound. The buyer pool for institutional-quality multifamily has also narrowed: many owners who bought during the earlier cycle can’t raise new funds, leaving fewer bidders for properties coming under pressure.
Barratt cites investor Howard Marks’s observation that buying from a forced seller can be attractive, while being forced to sell is costly. A loan maturity, he argues, creates a financing deadline that can shape a sale price regardless of the owner’s preferred timing.
Replacement costs offer one measure of value
Building a competing property has become more expensive. Construction costs are rising about 5% annually, JLL reported, while tariffs have pushed steel, aluminum and copper prices up by as much as 50%. Apartment prices have declined for a second consecutive year, and average capitalization rates are near 5.9%, compared with 4.4% in 2022.
Barratt points to a 300-plus-unit community in a coastal Southeast market that BAM Capital is under contract to buy. Completed in 2024, the property is priced a little above $200,000 per unit. Comparable properties trade in the high $250,000s per unit, while building the asset today would cost about $250,000 per unit. The submarket has no new market-rate apartments planned within five miles through 2030.
For Barratt, buying below replacement cost in a submarket with little competing construction creates a cushion against uncertain interest rates. Inflation is at 3.4%, energy prices are up 16%, and the Federal Reserve recently raised rates by a quarter point. He argues that apartment leases, which typically reset every 12 months, can respond to inflation more quickly than a 10-year bond.
Still, his case depends on careful pricing. Barratt says the current conditions demand stricter selection, and that BAM Capital will reject more opportunities than it pursues. The near-term test for the sector is whether buyers can find properties where demand, limited future supply and a discounted purchase price align before rent growth catches up with the easing construction pipeline.