Private Credit Pullback Could Increase Apartment Sales Across the Northeast and Sun Belt

| 5 min read

Private credit could deepen apartment distress

The risk to apartment owners may be less about today’s financing costs than whether lenders will still be willing to extend a lifeline. Private credit funds facing investor redemptions, weaker fundraising and rising losses could pull back from real estate, Danny Fishman, Gaia Real Estate’s co-founder and CEO, told Multifamily Dive. The Wall Street Journal has reported growing strain in private credit.

Fishman’s concern is that funds may have less capacity to rescue borrowers or refinance troubled deals. “I think we are starting to see more distress in the industry,” he said, adding that debt funds had helped owners postpone trouble for another year. “I think that comes to an end.” If you’re tracking potential sales, that shift matters: properties that had been kept afloat by refinancing may finally reach the market.

Gaia has experience buying under pressure. In 2012, it and Starwood Capital Group acquired about 9,500 apartment units through a bankruptcy auction. Since its founding, Gaia has purchased more than 20,000 residential units and managed roughly $4 billion in assets, according to a release shared with Multifamily Dive.

The firm sold nearly 20,000 units in 2021 and 2022, when apartment prices were at their peak, Fishman said. With values lower now, Gaia is rebuilding its portfolio in the Northeast and Sun Belt, including three recent South Florida purchases. Two properties came out of development: Gaia bought them and repaid their construction loans. The third was sold by a fund nearing the end of its life.

Refinancing pressure and volatile rates

Fishman expects more owners to face a choice between raising equity and selling. Many refinanced over the past three years using interest reserves, betting rates would fall and market conditions would improve. Those reserves are now depleted, he said. Owners with strong shareholders may be able to make a capital call; others may need to find new equity or put the property up for sale.

Treasury swings add another layer of uncertainty. A purchase or refinance can take two to three months, Fishman said, leaving borrowers exposed to rate moves between starting a deal and closing it. Rates can shift enough to change the spread after a borrower has locked financing, or make a hedge much more expensive.

That makes underwriting unusually difficult. Buyers can estimate taxes, insurance, operating expenses and rent, but they can’t reliably predict Treasury movements. Fishman said financing costs on a deal could rise by one percentage point before closing. “You can’t do an Excel on that.”

Picture of Danny Fishman, the CEO and Co-Founder of GAIA Real Estate.
Danny Fishman
Permission granted by Gaia Real Estate
 

Development remains hard to justify

High borrowing costs and a soft apartment market are keeping new projects from penciling out, Fishman said. In some cases, even free land wouldn’t make a multifamily development viable once construction costs and interest expense are included. That restraint could help the market recover and rents grow sooner by limiting new supply.

Fishman’s view is blunt: unless a developer needs to keep a large operation busy, the projected internal rate of return doesn’t support building now. The recovery, meanwhile, has taken longer than he expected. He attributes that partly to a larger-than-anticipated wave of new apartments and partly to weaker immigration. He said overall immigration to the U.S. had fallen to zero, making it difficult even for people seeking visas or green cards to enter the process; he described immigration as an important source of demand in many markets.

Local conditions are diverging

There are signs of improvement, but the map is uneven. Fishman said oversupply is easing in places such as Germantown, Tennessee, and described Atlanta as stronger. Some Nashville suburbs remain soft. Houston also varies by location: certain suburbs are struggling, while the inner city has strengthened. His read is that the market is beginning to stabilize, though broad regional labels can obscure what’s happening in individual submarkets.

New York is a sharp counterpoint to the Sun Belt’s softer areas. Fishman said the city has little apartment inventory and rents continue to rise; even he wonders how tenants can afford them. In Austin and Nashville, by contrast, renters may receive two months of concessions, which he equates to an effective rent cut of about 20%. For anyone comparing markets, the gap makes a single national recovery narrative hard to defend.

This interview has been edited for brevity and clarity.

Sign up to receive multifamily and apartment news in your inbox each weekday.

Source: Leslie Shaver · www.multifamilydive.com