Chico Foreclosure Suit Targets Fay Servicing Over Loss Mitigation Reviews

| 5 min read

The central issue in Matthew Del Real’s $25 million lawsuit against Fay Servicing is a narrow but consequential moment: the servicer reportedly urged him to submit an updated mortgage assistance application while a foreclosure sale was already scheduled for his Chico, California, home. The sale remained on the calendar, and Del Real filed suit on October 7, 2026, the day it was due to take place.

Del Real, a public school teacher representing himself, brought the case in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of California. The defendants named in the complaint are Fay Servicing, Fay Servicing LLC, Fay Financial LLC, Fay Group, U.S. Bank Trust National Association, Citigroup Mortgage Loan Trust 2023-A and Clear Recon Corp. He seeks $25 million in compensatory damages, punitive damages and a jury trial. The claims remain allegations; no court has ruled on them.

A loan transfer changed the course of the account

Del Real bought the Chico property in July 2011. According to his complaint, his original servicer, Wells Fargo Home Mortgage, handled the loan for more than a decade. After he faced financial difficulty in mid-2023, Wells Fargo granted him a six-month forbearance.

The loan then transferred to Fay Servicing. The complaint says Fay sent a welcome letter on December 11, 2023, alongside a separate notice warning that Del Real was behind on payments and that foreclosure could be initiated. A letter two days later identified Fay as a debt collector seeking payment for Citigroup Mortgage Loan Trust 2023-A. The first mortgage statement cited in the filing showed $15,151.08 due.

In May 2024, Fay allegedly sent a notice of default and intent to accelerate, stating that $22,994.67 was needed to cure the default. Del Real’s parents tried to help by sending two payments of $2,643.42, each equal to the monthly mortgage amount, in May and June. Fay returned both on July 1, the complaint says, explaining that the funds fell short of the minimum due. A representative allegedly told Del Real that partial payments would not be accepted.

Repeated applications and rising balances

Del Real’s first loss mitigation application followed in June 2024. He says he submitted several more over the next two years, but Fay repeatedly marked them incomplete or said information was missing. The complaint disputes those assessments, asserting that he consistently provided complete applications, and characterizes the rejections as predatory.

The filing also alleges that Fay assigned multiple account managers to the loan, which Del Real says failed to provide the single point of contact required under California’s Homeowner Bill of Rights.

The amounts cited in the complaint show how far the account had moved from its earlier monthly payment. A payoff statement in September 2025 put the total at $443,852.69. By September 2026, the reinstatement amount—the sum Del Real said he needed to bring the loan current and stop the sale—had reached $113,823.63.

The scheduled sale and the final application

The complaint says Fay’s September 2026 letter told Del Real that his mortgage remained delinquent and that a foreclosure sale was set for October 7. In the same letter, Fay encouraged him to send an updated loss mitigation application for review.

Del Real says he responded with a borrower assistance form, pay stubs, bank statements, proof of home insurance and a letter describing financial support. On September 22, less than two weeks before the sale, Fay allegedly sent an acknowledgement stating that the application remained incomplete and requesting additional documents. The complaint says Del Real promptly supplied them, completing the application before the sale date and the stated deadline.

The sale was scheduled for 3:30 p.m. on October 7 outside the Butte County Courthouse. Del Real filed his federal lawsuit that day. His account of these events frames the case’s dual tracking claim: whether foreclosure proceeded while a loss mitigation application was under review. Regulation X restricts servicers from taking specified foreclosure steps during certain pending application reviews.

Claims and cited enforcement history

Del Real’s complaint brings claims involving racial discrimination, wrongful foreclosure, dual tracking, the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act, the Real Estate Settlement Procedures Act, California’s Rosenthal Act and California’s Homeowner Bill of Rights. It alleges that the defendants’ handling of his applications created a racially hostile business relationship, describing him as a first-generation Mexican American. The wrongful foreclosure allegations include claims of fraudulent assignments, robo-signing and unanswered calls and emails.

The filing also points to two Consumer Financial Protection Bureau orders involving Fay Servicing. It cites a June 7, 2017, order concerning mortgage servicing practices and foreclosure prevention, then an August 21, 2024, order that it says found violations of the earlier order, Regulation X, the Homeowners Protection Act, Regulation Z and the Consumer Financial Protection Act. Those cited matters form part of Del Real’s argument; they do not establish the truth of his claims in this case.

For mortgage servicing teams, the dispute puts the timing of application requests under scrutiny. The complaint’s key sequence is the invitation to reapply, the request for more documents, and a sale date that remained in place. Whether that sequence violated federal or state requirements will be for the court to decide.

Source: James Williams · www.mpamag.com