North Carolina HELOC Lawsuit Puts Rocket Mortgage and Flagstar Servicing Transfer Under Scrutiny
A disputed servicing transfer turned a North Carolina couple’s $64,000 home equity line into a year-long series of payment, credit reporting and account access problems, according to a federal lawsuit. The case against Rocket Mortgage and Flagstar Bank shows how a breakdown at the point of transfer can affect borrowers’ ability to use existing credit and qualify for a new home loan.
Stephanie and Michael Princip filed suit on October 6, 2026, in the U.S. District Court for the Middle District of North Carolina. They allege that Flagstar’s transfer of their HELOC to Nationstar Mortgage LLC, doing business as Mr. Cooper and now Rocket Mortgage, was mishandled, followed by three separate suspensions of their draw privileges. The couple also says their credit scores fell by more than 130 points and that they received a pre-foreclosure notice.
These are allegations in a complaint; the court has not ruled on the claims. The plaintiffs bring claims under the Real Estate Settlement Procedures Act (RESPA), the Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA), and state contract law. Their account centers on a practical issue with direct housing market consequences: they say they couldn’t establish where or how to make payments while the credit line was being reported in ways they considered inaccurate.
Transfer communications left borrowers without a clear payment route
Flagstar transferred day-to-day servicing in April 2025. The complaint says Flagstar sent a farewell letter and followed with a welcome letter dated April 10, but that the welcome letter remained on Flagstar letterhead and did not give Rocket’s name, address or telephone number as the new servicer. The plaintiffs say Rocket never sent them a separate transfer notice.
Instructions on where to pay allegedly conflicted. Rocket’s website directed former Flagstar customers to send payments to Mr. Cooper, while the letter told the Princips to pay Flagstar. When they tried Rocket’s online system, the complaint says it could not verify their Social Security numbers. Searches using either the old or new loan number reportedly returned “no account found.”
Stephanie Princip contacted the servicer through Flagstar’s online portal in May 2025 and asked whether the payment should go to Mr. Cooper or Flagstar. The filing says the couple also encountered missing billing statements and a May payment that appeared as accepted in the portal but did not post to the account. The alleged problems left them with no reliable way to confirm that a payment had been credited.
Three suspensions followed different account explanations
The first suspension came on June 14, 2025, about 74 days after the transfer. The stated reason was that the account was past due. The Princips argue that any delinquency stemmed from the servicing failures: they say they lacked proper transfer information and statements, couldn’t complete online verification, and had a payment that was shown as accepted but never registered.
On October 31, the servicer suspended the HELOC again, this time citing a payoff request. The couple’s attorney had asked for a payoff statement in July. According to the complaint, the HELOC agreement did not list such a request as a reason to block draws, and correspondence from the servicer that day described the account as current.
The third suspension, issued June 9, 2026, was permanent and attributed to a “legal status review,” the suit says. It came six days after the servicer responded to the Princips’ third formal error notice. The plaintiffs allege the timing connects the suspension to their complaints under federal law; they say the loan was current at the time.
For a household relying on a revolving credit line, each interruption could affect access to available borrowing even if the account was current. The complaint describes three stated reasons across roughly a year, with the permanent restriction arriving while the borrowers were challenging how the account had been handled.
Formal complaints drew delayed and limited responses
Over about ten months, the Princips’ attorneys sent three formal notices disputing servicing errors, known as qualified written requests under RESPA. The complaint says the first, sent in July 2025, did not receive a response within the required period. The servicer later said its response had been returned because of an insufficient address; the couple says their address was correct.
The October 2025 notice received a response that the suit characterizes as boilerplate. It said the loan had been reviewed and complied with state and federal guidelines, and that “no error occurred.” The plaintiffs say it failed to address the payment attempts, missing statements, suspension decisions and requested breakdown of the interest rate.
A June 3, 2026 response acknowledged that the earlier replies “did not fully address the concerns raised” in the borrowers’ correspondence, according to the filing. But the couple alleges the later response still did not investigate their actual payment attempts. It attributed the system problems to standard new-account setup and again concluded that no system error had occurred.
Credit reporting dispute affected a planned home purchase
The complaint says the original HELOC tradeline was marked closed and transferred to another lender, with the credit limit shown as “N/A.” A replacement tradeline allegedly classified the revolving line as a mortgage account and home equity loan, listed the $64,000 limit as a high balance rather than a credit limit, and included stale balance data and zero payments received.
After Stephanie Princip disputed the reporting with TransUnion, the servicer reportedly verified the information as accurate while changing the account type, credit limit and rating. The plaintiffs say those changes demonstrate that the original reporting was wrong and that the dispute investigation was inadequate.
The couple alleges the resulting credit damage reduced their scores by more than 130 points and prevented them from securing pre-approval for a new purchase loan. The timing mattered to their housing plans: their primary adjustable-rate mortgage on the property was due to reset. The complaint also says they received a “North Carolina Forty-Five (45) Day Pre-Foreclosure Notice” around July 10, 2025, and that their home was registered with the State Home Foreclosure Prevention Project.
Damages sought and the case’s market relevance
The Princips seek actual damages, statutory damages under RESPA, punitive damages under the FCRA, and attorneys’ fees, and have demanded a jury trial. They calculate $12,000 against each defendant for the error-notice claims, based on $2,000 per violation per plaintiff, and seek another $4,000 from Rocket over the alleged failure to send a transfer notice.
For mortgage servicers, the complaint puts routine transfer operations in focus: borrower notices, account access, payment posting, credit reporting and responses to disputes. The Princips’ allegations describe how those processes can intersect with a household’s ability to draw on home equity and pursue another purchase. The claims remain untested, but the case’s central housing market question is concrete: whether a servicing change can leave borrowers unable to manage a credit line while their credit profile and financing plans are affected.