Buyer Hesitation Tests U.S. Housing Deals as Cancellations Rise

| 5 min read

Qualified buyers can still walk away when the numbers feel wrong. For mortgage broker Kevin Oto of Green Haven Capital, that hesitation reflects a broader challenge in the U.S. housing market: Redfin’s seasonally adjusted analysis of multiple listing service pending sales found that 14% of homes under contract in July had deals collapse, the highest share since November 2023.

That figure describes transactions that fell apart after a contract was signed; it doesn’t explain why each buyer changed course. Inspection, appraisal and financing issues account for many failed transactions. But when buyers have more properties to consider, uncertainty alone can put a deal at risk. A buyer may question whether the home is worth the agreed price, whether the monthly payment leaves enough room in the budget, or whether a concern that seemed manageable now feels harder to accept.

Oto’s response is to find out what’s driving the doubt, explain the available choices and address the issues that can be resolved. That approach doesn’t guarantee a transaction will close. It gives the buyer a clearer basis for deciding whether to proceed, renegotiate or step away.

Find the concern behind the hesitation

“Cold feet” can describe very different problems. A buyer may be unsettled by a higher-than-expected payment, the amount of savings needed at closing, an inspection finding or concern that the price is too high. Family advice and expectations that rates will fall can also affect the decision. The phrase can make these worries sound like a passing mood, when some point to a real mismatch between the buyer’s finances and the purchase.

Those concerns call for different responses. A payment that no longer fits the buyer’s budget might lead to a different loan structure or a lower price range. An inspection issue may call for a seller credit. A buyer worried about depleted savings could look for a way to preserve a larger cash reserve. Each option affects the transaction differently, so the broker needs to understand what the buyer is trying to protect before suggesting a next step.

In some cases, reviewing the figures is enough to clarify the decision. In others, the property or timing may not be right. That distinction matters: reassurance can help when confusion is the problem, but it won’t fix a purchase that the buyer can’t comfortably afford.

Give buyers choices they can act on

Buyers often look for certainty about future mortgage rates and home prices, or ask whether waiting six months would put them in a better position. Oto says those forecasts can’t be made with confidence, and points to the difficulty of timing rate changes consistently. His earlier discussion of that challenge is here.

Here's the thing: a forecast can sound precise without giving a buyer a reliable basis for deciding. Instead of building a decision around one, brokers can map out practical alternatives: adjust the loan structure, apply a seller credit toward closing costs or a rate buydown, reduce the purchase price to retain more cash, or wait. The point is to make clear that the buyer has more than one path, and to explain the tradeoffs each path brings.

That clarity can help buyers make a decision without needing to predict the market. If you're working in this space, the useful conversation is less about promising a better moment to buy and more about showing what the buyer can afford under the choices available now. As Oto puts it, confidence comes from knowing the available choices and having a plan.

A plan, not a prediction.

Affordability means more than loan approval

A borrower may qualify for a payment that still strains their day-to-day finances or conflicts with other goals. Oto argues that the useful measure is not simply the maximum amount underwriting will permit. Buyers also need room for savings, travel, investing and unexpected expenses. A monthly payment can meet a lender’s criteria and still leave too little flexibility for the household living with it.

That gap between approval and comfort is easy to miss when attention centers on the maximum loan amount. Buyers may focus on whether financing is available, while giving less thought to the costs and priorities that continue after closing. The numbers should be discussed in terms of the buyer’s own budget, not treated as a simple pass-or-fail threshold.

Discussing those limits at the outset can reduce the chance that a buyer feels trapped after finding a home. It also gives the broker a more useful reference point if the buyer later hesitates: the question becomes whether the purchase still fits the limits they identified, rather than whether they can be talked back into the deal. Oto has previously written about doing the upfront work needed to provide clarity in a crowded mortgage market in this piece.

Trust can mean advising a buyer to wait

For brokers, a successful conversation doesn’t always end with a completed transaction. The job is to explain the choices, identify the buyer’s actual concern and work through possible solutions. Sometimes that leads to an offer; sometimes it leads to a pause. Treating a pause as a failure can push a buyer toward a decision that hasn’t addressed the underlying concern.

Oto’s view is that clients are more likely to trust guidance when they know their broker will say when the figures don’t work. That’s a practical test of the relationship: the broker’s advice has value only if it leaves room for the buyer to decline. And yet, a broker can still help the buyer understand which concerns are solvable and which signal that the transaction no longer fits.

What a higher cancellation share means for buyer confidence

The reported 14% share signals that a signed contract doesn’t always settle a buyer’s doubts. The figure alone doesn’t show whether cancellations stemmed from affordability, property condition, financing or other causes, so it shouldn’t be read as a measure of any one problem. Still, it puts the work of explaining costs and options in sharper focus: buyers may need clear answers after the offer, when new information or second thoughts surface.

This is more significant than it looks. A broker who listens closely can help distinguish ordinary uncertainty from a concern that deserves a change in terms or a decision to stop. That doesn’t remove the uncertainty from buying a home, but it can make the next choice more grounded. In a market where hesitation can break a deal, careful listening and clear options may do more to sustain buyer confidence than pressure.

Qualified buyers with cold feet need options, not pressure

Source: Richard Martinez · www.mpamag.com