Luxury Home Prices Outpaced Starter Homes in 70% of Major US Markets
Luxury home prices rose faster than starter-home prices in about 70% of the major US markets tracked by First American in September. The split points to a widening difference in how buyers are absorbing borrowing costs: entry-level purchasers face tighter monthly budgets, while luxury buyers are generally less dependent on financing. That distinction matters because a single national price-growth figure can conceal very different conditions across the market. When buyers at one end can keep competing while buyers at the other pull back, the same interest-rate increase can produce different price results by tier.
The September figures offer a snapshot before mortgage rates climbed to a three-year high in October. National annual price growth eased to 1.2%, its weakest September reading since 2011, when prices were falling. Prices were flat from August; the July-to-August increase remained 0.2%. The annual and monthly measures tell related but different stories: the annual figure shows how much prices changed over a year, while the flat monthly reading points to little immediate movement at the national level. A slowdown in growth isn’t the same as a broad price decline.
“That gap reflects how higher mortgage rates affect buyers differently,” said Mark Fleming, First American’s chief economist. Buyers at the lower end have less room to manage higher payments, he said, while luxury purchasers are typically less constrained by financing costs. The contrast is plausible, but it shouldn’t be read as proof that every luxury buyer pays cash or that every first-time buyer is equally stretched. It describes a market pattern: buyers with more room in their budgets can be less sensitive to financing costs, while modest changes in monthly payments can force others to reconsider what they can afford.
Affordability weighs on entry-level demand
First-time buyers made up 63.3% of agency purchase loans in May, according to First American. That share indicates how much the purchase market depends on households entering homeownership, though it doesn’t show how many potential buyers were unable to secure a loan. A long-running shortage of affordable homes continues to support starter-home values, Fleming said, but affordability pressures are limiting the pace of gains. Scarcity can keep prices firm even when demand weakens; it doesn’t make the homes easier to buy.
Demand indicators have weakened alongside higher rates. The Mortgage Bankers Association’s seasonally adjusted Purchase Index fell 7% in the week ending October 16, while FHA loans accounted for 16.3% of applications. Purchase applications ran 18% below the same period a year earlier, as higher rates priced some buyers out, said MBA deputy chief economist Joel Kan. These figures capture application activity, not completed home sales, so they’re best read as a signal of demand rather than a direct count of purchases. Still, the year-over-year decline gives context to the strain buyers face.
Here’s the thing: a limited supply of lower-priced homes can support their values while shrinking the pool of households able to compete for them. That can leave first-time buyers facing both higher financing costs and fewer affordable choices. If you’re working in this space, the tier split is a reminder that “the housing market” can describe very different experiences depending on a buyer’s budget.
October rates put September’s figures in context
Existing-home sales increased 1.5% in September, reaching a 3.99 million annual rate, but remained 2.2% below the year-earlier level, the National Association of Realtors reported. The 30-year fixed mortgage rate averaged 6.86% that month. NAR chief economist Lawrence Yun said subsequent rate increases meant fewer buyers could qualify. The September sales improvement and the annual decline can both be true: one is a month-to-month comparison, the other measures activity against the same month a year earlier.
Freddie Mac reported that its 30-year fixed rate reached 7.40% in mid-October, the highest level in three years, then eased to 7.32% for the week ending October 22. That weekly easing offered some relief, but it followed a sustained climb and didn’t erase the higher borrowing costs buyers had been confronting. Rate movements can change quickly; households planning a purchase often have to make decisions within the conditions they can actually lock in.
First American estimates that the increase from roughly 6.5% in July to just above 7% in September reduced house-buying power by about $19,000 for households with unchanged incomes. Fleming said higher rates could further limit affordability and reinforce rate lock-in, keeping some owners from listing and reducing both sales demand and the supply of homes. The pressure can work on both sides of the transaction: prospective buyers may qualify for less, while owners with existing mortgages may have less reason to sell. Fewer listings can make the search harder even as fewer buyers are able to bid.
CME FedWatch pricing put the probability of the Federal Reserve holding rates at its October 27–28 meeting at 90.6%, following a September hike. The market-implied chance of a December increase was 79.7%. Those probabilities describe market expectations at the time; they aren’t a record of what the Federal Reserve ultimately did. For housing, the immediate issue in these figures is the cost of borrowing and its effect on purchasing power, regardless of how traders were positioning for a later policy decision.
Midwestern markets post gains as Texas metros fall
Regional results varied sharply. Grand Rapids led starter-tier appreciation at 5.5%, while its mid-tier and luxury prices rose 3.5% and 3.4%. Milwaukee recorded gains of 5.2% for starter homes, 3.8% for the mid-tier and 5.1% for luxury homes. Cleveland’s respective increases were 5.1%, 4.0% and 5.3%. The gains across several price tiers suggest that strength in these markets wasn’t confined to one buyer segment, although the figures alone don’t explain what drove each local result.
In Philadelphia, the three tiers rose 5.0%, 3.4% and 3.3%. Chicago’s starter and mid-tier prices each gained 4.7%, while luxury prices climbed 6.3%. Chicago led overall annual appreciation at 5.1%, followed by New York at 4.9% and Hartford, Connecticut, at 4.7%. Cleveland and Milwaukee each gained 4.6% overall. The difference between tier-level and overall figures is a useful caution: a metro’s headline result can mask stronger movement in one part of its market and weaker movement in another.
Four of the five large metros with annual price declines were in Texas. Dallas fell 6.3%, Austin 4.3%, San Antonio 2.7% and Houston 2.0%; Seattle was down 2.6%. That concentration marks a clear regional contrast with the listed Midwestern gains, but it doesn’t establish a single cause for the declines. Local price measures can reflect different balances of supply and demand, and the figures here don’t identify which factors mattered most in each metro. The numbers here are underwhelming for those markets, especially alongside the stronger appreciation elsewhere.
What the figures suggest for the months ahead
First American Data & Analytics, part of First American Financial Corporation in Santa Ana, California, released the house price index on October 26. It tracks prices with a lag of less than four weeks and divides sales into three price tiers within the nation, all 50 states and the 50 largest core-based statistical areas. That structure makes it possible to compare price movement across tiers and regions, but the results remain a snapshot of completed market activity rather than a real-time account of every buyer’s experience.
The September results show that entry-level demand is more exposed to the rate squeeze, even as limited supply continues to support prices. That tension is likely to remain central to how readers interpret future price and sales reports: weaker purchasing power can slow demand, while constrained supply can keep prices from falling in step. And yet, the regional spread shows why national averages need context. This is more significant than it looks. A market can post modest national growth while buyers in some metros see declines and those in others face rising prices across several tiers.
For now, the figures describe an uneven market, not a uniform turn in one direction. Buyers’ financing constraints, owners’ decisions about listing and local conditions all shape how higher rates show up in prices and sales. The September data can’t settle what happens next. A pause in price growth, with regional gains and declines continuing side by side.