VantageScore Gains Ground in U.S. Mortgage Lending as Fannie Mae Reports 37% Adoption

| 5 min read

VantageScore 4.0 is moving quickly into U.S. mortgage underwriting: 37% of conventional applications created in Fannie Mae’s Desktop Underwriter system in September included the score. The shift gives lenders another way to assess borrowers as Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac apply the same loan-level price adjustments to VantageScore and Classic FICO loans.

FHFA Director Bill Pulte has framed the change as a challenge to FICO’s longstanding position in mortgage lending. “Abusive monopolies will not be allowed to take advantage of consumers anywhere in the mortgage market,” he wrote on X on Monday. In September, he claimed FICO had raised its per-person credit score price by 1,800% since 2020.

Pulte targets FICO ‘monopolies’ while lenders shift to VantageScore

A single pricing grid changes the comparison

For loans issued or settled on or after October 1, Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac use the same loan-level price adjustments (LLPAs) for Classic FICO and VantageScore 4.0. Lenders choosing VantageScore must request scores from all three credit repositories.

Previously, lenders had to subtract 20 points from a borrower’s VantageScore before pricing the loan. Desmond Smith, executive vice president and chief growth officer at United Wholesale Mortgage, said some borrowers with a FICO score of 642 received a VantageScore of 708. That difference can put a borrower in a different LLPA tier.

Pulte announced the shared pricing approach in September, saying Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac would add VantageScore to the existing FICO Classic grid. In April, he directed the two enterprises to update their selling guides to include VantageScore and FICO Score 10T. His September 4 directive then opened VantageScore 4.0 to all mortgage originators selling loans to the enterprises.

That move ended a pilot that began May 1 with 50 lenders. During the pilot, VantageScore was used in more than 9% of the mortgages Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac securitized. VantageScore was created jointly by Experian, Equifax and TransUnion; Classic FICO has been the mortgage industry’s standard for decades.

Lenders are putting the score into use

Rocket Mortgage plans to make VantageScore 4.0 its preferred model for eligible direct-to-consumer loans. The company said borrowers who saved money using the score saved an average of $1,600 at closing. Rocket Pro, its broker channel, will continue to offer both scores.

Pennymac has introduced VantageScore 4.0 across its consumer-direct, broker and correspondent businesses. For correspondent loans using the score, it requires a tri-merge credit report containing both Classic FICO and VantageScore 4.0 for every borrower.

FICO, meanwhile, said it would keep its wholesale mortgage price at $10 for lenders and brokers in its Preferred Program. The price covers a bundle that includes Classic FICO and FICO Score 10T.

Credit report costs remain a point of pressure

The scoring changes are unfolding amid debate over the cost and contents of mortgage credit reports. Brokers reported in January that tri-merge credit pulls cost more than $200. The Mortgage Bankers Association has urged FHFA to require just one score for borrowers with a score of 700 or higher.

A bi-merge option remains under consideration. Dan Smith, president and CEO of the Consumer Data Industry Association, has argued that keeping tri-merge reports “is critical to the safety and soundness of the mortgage industry.” Pulte canceled an in-person appearance at the convention, where he had been expected to address the issue.

Rates keep affordability in focus

The change in scoring is arriving while mortgage rates remain above 7%. Freddie Mac reported that the average 30-year fixed rate slipped from 7.4% to 7.32% last week. Rates had otherwise risen alongside bond yields and oil prices, which the source attributes to the Iran war.

The 10-year Treasury yield fell nearly 20 basis points on October 22 after a technology stock selloff. Markets expected the Federal Reserve to pause that week after a quarter-point increase at its previous meeting, with another increase expected in December.

VantageScore’s growing presence in applications shows lenders are testing the model at scale. The next measure of its reach will be how often its scores shape pricing and loan decisions as lenders expand their use of the shared grid.

Source: Joseph Williams · www.mpamag.com