New York Landlord Fees Face Class Action Challenge After Appeals Ruling

| 5 min read

Fees tied to a tenant’s departure

New York landlords could face a broader challenge to fixed reletting and early termination fees after an appeals court revived a tenant’s bid to pursue class claims against Ninety Five Wall Street LLC. The ruling keeps open whether lease terms that charge departing tenants regardless of how quickly a unit is re-rented conflict with the state’s duty to mitigate damages. That question matters because a charge described as compensation for a landlord’s losses may work differently when it’s due even if those losses don’t occur.

Two fees at the center of the dispute

The Appellate Division, First Department, partially reversed the dismissal on October 22, 2026. It reinstated a claim that the landlord acted in bad faith by collecting charges allegedly inconsistent with tenant protections, along with a request for a ruling that the fee provisions are void. The decision allows those arguments to continue; it doesn’t decide that the fees are unlawful or that the tenant’s account has been proven.

The lease required a “reletting charge,” described as “a reasonable estimate of such damages,” payable even if the landlord failed to find a replacement tenant. A separate buyout agreement set an early termination charge of two months’ rent, including when the landlord secured a replacement at the same rent immediately. The two provisions therefore raise related but distinct questions: what loss the reletting charge is meant to estimate, and whether the buyout amount remains due regardless of what happens to the apartment.

The tenant argued both charges ran against Real Property Law Section 227-e, which requires landlords to make reasonable efforts to re-rent a unit after a tenant leaves. The statute also voids lease terms that waive that duty to mitigate damages. In practical terms, the dispute asks whether a landlord can collect a fixed departure fee while still being required to limit losses by seeking a replacement tenant. The answer may depend on how the provisions operate, not simply on the labels attached to them.

Why the court let the claims proceed

The tenant’s central point was that a fixed charge could erase the protection Section 227-e provides. If the landlord re-rents promptly, the departing tenant might owe no damages; a fee collected regardless of the outcome could still impose a cost. That’s the tension the court allowed the case to test: a payment framed as an estimate of loss may be difficult to square with a duty to reduce that loss if it’s charged without regard to the result.

The landlord described the fees as a fair agreement and argued there were no damages to mitigate because the tenant hadn’t breached the lease. The appellate panel found the allegations sufficient to continue the case. It said the state’s implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing bars conduct that undermines another party’s contractual rights, and could cover an alleged attempt to collect charges prohibited by Section 227-e. At this stage, the panel’s conclusion concerns whether the claim can proceed, rather than whether the landlord ultimately violated that covenant.

The panel also rejected the idea that the result turned on whether the charges counted as pre-set damage estimates. As the court put it, “they still have to be enforceable in light of this State’s public policy, which includes Real Property Law § 227-e.” Calling a charge an agreed estimate doesn’t settle whether it fits the statute. The court’s reasoning leaves room for both questions to matter: how the fee was designed and whether collecting it would undermine the tenant protection at issue.

Class claims return to trial court

The court revived a separate claim seeking a class-wide decision on whether the lease terms are enforceable under Section 227-e. It treated that question as distinct from the tenant’s individual circumstances. A class-wide challenge could focus on the language and operation of the provisions across affected leases, while the tenant’s own facts may bear on individual claims. The court hasn’t certified a class, so the scope of any group case remains unsettled.

A separate unjust enrichment claim remains dismissed because the written agreements cover the dispute. That distinction narrows the route ahead: the revived claims rest on the statute, the alleged bad faith, and the enforceability of the contract terms, rather than on a general claim that the landlord retained a benefit unfairly. The case now returns to the trial court, where class certification and the merits remain unresolved.

The tenant is represented by Bursor and Fisher. If the case proceeds on a class basis and the legal theory succeeds, landlords using similar fee structures across New York could face challenges. The ruling doesn’t establish that every flat fee is invalid; its reach will depend on the provisions and arguments developed as the case continues. Still, this is more significant than it looks: the court has allowed tenants to question whether a fee can stand when its amount doesn’t respond to the landlord’s actual efforts or outcome.

What landlords and tenants should watch

For landlords and property managers, the ruling puts standard lease language involving flat reletting or early termination charges back in focus, especially where the amount doesn’t change when a unit is quickly re-rented. The practical issue is whether the fee’s stated purpose matches how it’s charged. A provision that operates the same way whether a unit sits vacant or is promptly occupied may invite closer scrutiny under the theory the tenant has advanced (and this is the part most people overlook).

For tenants, the case keeps open a challenge to fees that may be due even when a landlord finds a replacement at the same rent. But the current decision doesn’t resolve what any tenant owes under a particular lease, and it doesn’t establish a class-wide result. If you’re working in this space, the useful signal is narrower: courts may examine the effect of fixed charges alongside the statutory duty to mitigate, rather than treating the contract’s description of a fee as the end of the analysis.

More litigation will be needed to clarify how that analysis applies to these agreements. The distinction between a charge tied to actual loss and one imposed automatically could become central as the claims proceed. For now, the appellate decision restores the questions for trial court review. A live dispute, not a settled rule.

Source: Richard Garcia · www.mpamag.com