Magnolia Cove HOA Fees Set to Reach $2,500 a Month in 2027

| 5 min read

Magnolia Cove residents face a sharp rise in HOA fees. Picture: Supplied


For Magnolia Cove’s 80 households, a planned monthly assessment of $2,500 from January 1, 2027, shifts the homeowners association fee from a routine carrying cost to a serious strain on household budgets. Owners in the Catawba County, North Carolina, subdivision say the increase could put their ability to stay in their homes at risk, particularly alongside mortgage payments.

One resident, speaking anonymously to Realtor.com® over concern about legal retaliation, said the increase could mean leaving the house and losing the equity they hoped to pass on to their son and his family. The homeowner said finding another place to live would also add expense.

Owners say the fee changes have caught them off guard. Picture: Supplied


A budget dominated by legal bills

The fee path has been steep. Resident Jill Menson told WSOC that assessments were $158 a month four years ago, then rose to $350 and later to $1,250 earlier this year. At a Monday evening meeting, the developer-controlled HOA said the 2027 monthly charge would be $2,500.

That figure was lower than the $7,500 per month residents had been told to expect before the meeting. An email circulated to owners tied the proposed $7,500 assessment to an annual base assessment of $90,000 per lot and a total base assessment budget of $2.07 million. The email attributed the increase mainly to legal and collection expenses linked to unpaid owner accounts, adding that owners who pay on time help reduce those costs over time.

The proposed budget, prepared using the higher monthly figure, allocated $1.1 million to legal fees—more than half of its $2.07 million total. It set aside $96,000 for landscaping maintenance and $95,500 for landscaping refresh and installation. The final assessment announced at the meeting is $2,500 a month, but the figures give residents a clear view of how legal expenses have come to shape the association’s finances.

Some owners say the new assessments could make staying unaffordable. Picture: Supplied


Dispute over the association’s finances

The current dispute follows years of tension between residents and the HOA, which is run by Magnolia Cove developer Aaron Guess and his company, Story Homes. In 2022, residents told WSOC that promised amenities, including a pool and mailboxes, had not been delivered, and raised concerns about financial transparency.

More than 20 homeowners sued the HOA in early 2024. According to a statement from the association, the claims were either voluntarily dropped or dismissed, and none went to a jury. The HOA then brought a defamation case against the homeowners. A jury found them liable and awarded monetary and punitive damages; the amounts are due to be determined at a further trial next year, the statement said.

The association says defending the claims produced substantial legal bills that now make up its largest budget item. It also points to widespread delinquency in assessments, arguing that unpaid balances shift costs to owners who continue paying. The HOA describes those two pressures—the litigation expense and past-due accounts—as the basis for the $2,500 monthly assessment.

The board says it does not want to maintain fees at this level and aims to reduce assessments after legal costs and overdue accounts are addressed. For residents, that leaves an uncertain timeline: the association says bills must be covered in the meantime, while some owners may not be able to absorb the increase for long.

Residents worry the rising fees could force them out. Picture: Supplied


Affordability concerns remain

The Catawba County Register of Deeds records show at least one Magnolia Cove resident facing foreclosure after a lien was placed on the home. The available information does not establish whether that foreclosure is connected to HOA assessments.

Greta Turillo, founder of the HOA Accountability Project in North Carolina, told Realtor.com that impact litigation, homeowner education, public awareness and housing choice are needed to improve HOA practices across the state. “That is the only way that North Carolina is going to see meaningful change in the HOA industry,” she said.

For Magnolia Cove, the immediate question is whether owners can carry the higher assessments while the association works through its legal bills and unpaid accounts. The announced $2,500 monthly charge is a sharp change from the community’s earlier fee levels, and residents’ ability to remain in their homes will depend in part on how quickly those cost pressures ease.

Source: William Smith · www.realestate.com.au