Multifamily Refinancing Gap Puts $6.8B of Equity in Focus

| 5 min read

For apartment owners facing near-term loan maturities, access to refinancing is only part of the decision. CRED iQ estimates that roughly $6.8 billion in new equity may be needed across a $136 billion pool of multifamily debt coming due from October 2026 through December 2028. That estimate points to a gap between the debt coming due and the amount new loans can support under current assumptions. The harder question for owners is whether putting in more capital will protect value for existing investors—or merely postpone a difficult reckoning.

A sizable refinancing shortfall

CRED iQ resized multifamily loans in Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac and commercial mortgage-backed securities deals scheduled to mature during that period. Its analysis found that 23% of the loans, representing 31% of the outstanding balance, couldn’t refinance without an equity contribution. The difference between the share of loans and the share of debt matters: the shortfall is concentrated in loans that account for a larger portion of the total balance.

The firm separately described the share of maturing apartment debt requiring a cash infusion as nearly 33%. The two figures use different descriptions of the exposure, so they shouldn’t be treated as interchangeable measures. Either way, they point to a meaningful funding gap, even as capital remains available to borrowers. Availability alone doesn’t tell owners whether the amount, cost or conditions of that capital make a refinance workable.

That distinction matters. A loan may be obtainable, but the terms can make the equity requirement much larger than owners once expected. A refinance can therefore solve the immediate maturity problem while shifting more of the burden onto existing investors. Earlier this year, Maximiliane Leachman, vice chair of CBRE’s debt and structured finance group, said some lenders that had sought extensions equal to 1% to 3% of a loan balance were now asking for as much as 10%. That’s a substantial change in the cash borrowers may need to keep a loan in place.

Leachman also raised the prospect of borrowers returning to debt funds for a second modification near year-end. “It will be interesting to see how many of those go back,” she said. A second modification could buy time, but time alone doesn’t improve a property’s income or reduce its debt burden. The outcome depends on whether the operating picture changes enough to support the next financing decision.

Can the deal support another capital call?

For owners, the calculation goes beyond the size of the refinancing gap. Michael Lynd, CEO of Kairoi Residential, said the cost of a new loan can further weaken the position of existing equity holders if expected rent growth doesn’t arrive soon. In that situation, owners face a mismatch: financing costs come due on a schedule, while improved revenue may take longer to materialize.

“If rent growth doesn’t show up in that first six to nine months or a year, then you have a chance of further impairing the equity value that isn't in place,” Lynd said.

That timing risk complicates the choice between refinancing and selling. Lynd said some groups may hold a property rather than record a loss, or seek more capital to delay a sale. A capital call can keep a transaction from happening immediately, but it asks investors to commit more money based on the prospect of future performance. That’s a demanding case to make when the property’s income hasn’t yet caught up with its financing costs.

And yet, selling can make the loss visible and final. A refinancing that keeps an asset off the market can still leave investors carrying higher costs without the operating gains needed to justify them. This is more significant than it looks: a completed refinance may appear to resolve the maturity, while the underlying question of equity value remains open.

“You can get a loan, but should you take that loan? Is that the best risk-adjusted decision for your equity?” Lynd said.

Numbers need a deal-level read

The CRED iQ estimate gives owners a broad measure of the exposure, but it doesn’t settle what any individual borrower should do. Portfolio-wide totals can show how much debt may face a funding gap; they can’t establish whether a particular property can support a new loan. Property performance, financing terms and the timing of rent growth will shape whether new equity can support a refinance or simply deepen the impairment.

Multifamily professionals are surrounded by studies and forecasts, and data can be assembled to support competing views of the market. The maturity figures are a useful signal of pressure, but they don’t describe every property’s prospects or every lender’s terms. Here's the thing: a broad estimate is a starting point for scrutiny, not a substitute for examining the asset’s income, costs and proposed debt together.

What the maturity figures mean for owners

As maturities approach, owners will have to weigh the cash required to refinance against the likely cost of waiting, selling or contributing more equity. Similar financing situations typically turn on the property’s ability to generate enough income to carry the new debt, but the source figures don’t establish how that will play out for any specific asset. If you're working in this space, the useful question is whether a proposed loan leaves the property room to absorb weaker-than-expected rent growth.

Some decisions may come down to a narrow window between the loan maturity and the point when operating performance can support the debt. (And this is the part most people overlook.) More capital can preserve an option, but it doesn’t guarantee that the option will pay off. A financing solution on paper. As maturities approach, the deal-level test will matter more than the availability of capital alone.

Source: Leslie Shaver · www.multifamilydive.com